Monday, September 5, 2011

Blog post #3: Tutorial responses

Emphasis
1. Describe where your attention is visually drawn in this text. What strategies does the author use to emphasize this element? Given that this text is essentially a title page for a larger project, does this emphasis seem effective to you? Why or why not?
  
A: Visually, my attention is drawn towards the pen and paper, and what is being written down. It appears that the author chose to use a very cluttered background to make the notepad stand out and become the center of attention. The bigger handwritten words also stand out, forcing the audience to take a closer look at what is being said.

2. Between composing the two different pages ("Digital Rights Management/Digital Robbing Maniacs" and "Criminal") the woman disappears from the screen and the jumpy stop-motion effect ceases. Describe how this moment of stillness can be understood as "emphasis" and explain if it seems like an effective strategy? What is emphasized by stopping the movement?  

A: In the frozen shots without the woman in the picture, I feel like the words on the notepad become very emphasized. This is an effective strategy because when everything halts, it gives the audience time to "step in" and take a closer look without the woman being somewhat distracting in the picture. 


3. Consider the role sound plays in emphasis. How does the soundtrack to this clip help to (a) emphasize certain moments in the clip, and (b) place a particular emotional emphasis on the meaning of the clip?


A: The soundtrack to this video emphasizes focus and determination with the piano/beat and seems to sync up well with the stop motion nature of the clip. When the image freezes the first time, the soundtrack changes it's pitch, bringing the audience closer. The soundtrack plays an important role when it comes to properly emphasizing something in a clip like this.

Contrast
1. Watch 0:22-0:36 of The JUMP's "Call for Papers." Notice the words, the gray box, the cartoon background, and the sound. Do you think any of these elements contrast? If so, which ones and how so (specifically, what makes them different from one another)? What effects do you think this use of contrast has on the audience and the purpose? Consider how the text's effectiveness might change if these elements did not contrast.


A: The gray box is somewhat transparent, as you can still slightly view the cartoon through it. The box does contrast with the cartoon (though it shares the same dull looking color), and successfully allows the audience to read the scrolling text without being distracted by the cartoon. The narration seems to do a good job at keeping you focused on the text. I feel like the biggest contrast would be the actual soundtrack/electronic narration vs the old cartoon because the author blended futuristic sounds into an old/less technologically advanced looking cartoon. If these two did not contrast with each other at all, I think there would be a loss of interest in the clip and the audience would become more distracted. Clips like this need contrast to be effective at getting a point across.


2. Watch 0:55-1:08 of The JUMP's "Call for Papers." Notice how this is similar to the clip from question 1, yet the background no longer includes the cartoon. First, describe what elements are contrasting. Next, explain why you think the cartoon background was deleted from this section. What happens to the contrast now that the background is black? Which element is now the most emphasized, and how do you think this helps convey the purpose of the text?

A: The black background contrasts with the creme colored text and includes narration that reads the text. I think the cartoon background was deleted from this section because it's just another element that could potentially distract the audience from the main point the author is trying to make, specifically during this part of the clip. The contrast suddenly becomes much simpler and brings the audience back into focus. I think the most emphasized element during this part of the clip is the soundtrack: Narration and background music combined. Together, they paint a clear picture for the audience, emphasizing what the "two papers" are about.

3. Imagine you've been asked to design a flyer to post around your campus advertising The JUMP. What would the flyer look like? Which element(s) would contrast and to what effect? 

A: The flyer would have the 1960's style cartoon drawings and colors, but the text used on the flyer would be modern looking to go along with the contrast of being old school mixed with the modern music/narration. The summarize, the modern text style would be in contrast with the old style cartoon.

Organization
1. Choose 5 of the 15 images to drag into the empty timeline. Make a note about each of the 5 photos to explain what each one signifies, and how one leads to another. How does your organization convey your purpose?

A: The sequence I created: "modern", people cheering, man smoking, dairy isle, and what looks to be a garbage pile icon.
Though this is somewhat of a random order of events, I tried to begin with the "modern" icon representing what our society has become. The next photo, people cheering, represents freedom, as does the next image of a man smoking. The 2nd to last icon, of dairy products leading into the last photo, a garbage pile, represents the negative effects of our society. Since I wasn't able to view larger images of these icons, I'm not really sure if my descriptions were accurate.  


2. Are there different arguments that you could have made by organizing your 5 photos in different ways?


A: By arranging them in different ways, the sequence of events could have told a complete different story in a positive or negative way.


3. Are there other elements you could add to make your argument stronger—for example, playing music with the slide show or adding text?

A: I think if I added text to the icons, it would make for a much easier read and would make more sense. 

Alignment
 1. How would you describe alignment of the words "murmuring" and "insects" in the opening scene? How does the unusual alignment (reflected on screen and timed) add to your interpretation of the text?


A: The words "murmuring" and "insects" align themselves in a visually appealing way as they morph into their reflections. I honestly don't have too much of an interpretation of this text, since it is relatively simple. 

2. Now watch the "Earth" scene. What other elements are aligned in this scene? How does the consistent alignment of elements across screens (and also across some of the scenes) affect how you read these scenes? What elements do you end up focusing on? Would the scene seem as effective if all of the elements on the page (upside-down moon, contrails, words, background color, etc.) had no shared alignment?

A: "In the weeds", "murmuring", and "insects" all fall into alignment directly under the earth icon. With these being aligned specifically under the earth, I feel that the author is emphasizing something, or hinting a deeper meaning.
I focus on the falling/morphing text, and the change in background color. If there was no shared alignment in the earth scene, I feel that this piece wouldn't be as effective/make sense.


3. Now watch the "Air" scene, paying attention to the lines of poetry and the audio tracks. The poem doesn't settle on the same horizontal axis as the other scenes do, and the two phrases in the audio track are aligned (synced) to appear with each line of poetry. Why do you think the alignments of the words are different between the Earth and Air scenes? What is the significance of the audio track's content in relation to that difference?


A: The alignment of the words are different in this scene because I think the author wanted to emphasize a different meaning for the falling text.  (to be continued..)


Proximity
1. Did you group certain categories of information together? How did you group them—typographically, by placing them closer together, or in some other way?

A: I placed the seagull icon close to large "the Seagull" text but far from the authors name.

2. What do you think is the most important piece of information on your cover? What choices did you make about typeface or size to convey that sense of importance? How does the layout of your book cover reflect your sense of how the information should be organized? 

A: The most important piece of information on the cover is the tiny text "A novel about flight" under the title "The Seagull." I wanted the text to be small yet noticeable, as it is just that extra bit of information about the novel. The layout of the book cover gives a sense of knowledge, as it is really a clean layout.


3. What are some limitations you've encountered in laying out visual elements in a traditional way? What are some other ways you might want to organize the information on a book cover that might work better in a non-traditional format?

A: Laying out visual elements in a traditional way is just uneventful and cliche. It doesn't grab the audience and doesn't stand out. Organizing the book cover so that things are not only centered, but off to the side/cut off/abstract looking will make it work better.
 
 

1 comment:

  1. Might I just say...you were doing a fantastic job in this class, and I know you'll do great once you come back. Take care and we'll see you in the Spring!

    ReplyDelete